Goat's Milk Caramel Duo - Pick Two

By Fat Toad Farm


* Required Fields

  • We're sorry, but this product isn't eligible for free shipping
Add to Wishlist


Fat Toad Farm's decadently delicious goat's milk caramel sauce is made the traditional Mexican way with fresh local goat's milk and a few simple natural ingredients.

  • Materials: Goat milk and organic sugar mixed with a variety of natural ingredients
  • Care: Refrigerate after opening
  • Comes in unique, rich flavors
  • Each jar is 8 oz.
  • Dimensions (in packaging): 4" x 4" x 8"
  • Weight: 4.8 lbs.
    Individual Flavor Information:
  • Original: Traditional recipe using goat milk and organic sugar
  • Salted Bourbon: Original recipe infused with Kentucky straight bourbon and organic sea salt while the caramel is cooking
  • Vanilla Bean: Original recipe infused with whole organic vanilla beans while cooking
  • Cinnamon: Original recipe infused with whole organic cinnamon sticks while cooking
  • Spicy Dark Chocolate: Original recipe combined with the complexity of Taza Mexican stoneground chocolate and a zip of cayenne
  • Cold Brew: Original recipe infused with cold brew coffee while cooking
  • Vermont Maple: Original recipe infused with whole organic vanilla beans while cooking combined with creamy caramel richness and the subtle tang of goat's milk

25 Reviews (4.9 out of 5 Grommets)

Sorted by Rating

Love this stuff

4/6/2019 by Lois

Have ordered several times. Sort of surprised a neighbor who is picky about what she eats likes most of the flavors also. Goes great over ice cream, waffles and pancakes. I really like the spicy and coffee flavors but have tried most and like all I have tried.More > < Less


Love it

1/31/2019 by Lois

Bought a pair for Christmas gifts. Have already gotten another pair. A little tangy but great flavors. Have tried the coffee, spicy and maple flavors. No complaints. Great on ice cream, pancakes and wafflesMore > < Less



10/18/2018 by Susan

Love this caramel sauce, especially on chocolate ice cream. Will consider giving as a gift when I need one. Would make a nice hostess gift.


High quality product

7/26/2018 by Kate

This product is a delight. Cleverly labeled, excellent taste. Quality jars that survived several nights of 40 below zero weather on my front step. (A misstep with our local Fed Ex delivery.) Jars were rescued, allowed to thaw for several days and survived in great condition.More > < Less


Caramel sauce is amazing!

6/19/2018 by Jennifer

We tried the Spicy Dark CHocolate and the Caramel, spicy was ok, don't think I would try it again, but love the caramel and want to try next the vanilla bean one. Def will buy from Fat Toad Farm again~ well packaged and came on timeMore > < Less

Items 1 to 5 of 25 total

Fat Toad Farm - Goats Milk Caramel

About Fat Toad Farm

Caramel-icious Confections

Fat Toad Farm is a family-run goat dairy in Brookfield, Vermont. It was started as a raise-your-own-food effort, but when the herd grew from 2 to 12 to 25 and started producing much more milk than one family could drink, Fat Toad Farm became a certified goat dairy. Today the family—Steve Reid, Judith Irving, Calley Hastings, and Josey Hastings—fills various roles on the farm and in the production room.

It’s Fat Toad’s somewhat unusual goat milk caramel that caught our eye. Josey has lived in Mexico on and off for the past decade, and there she discovered cajeta, a popular caramel sauce made from goat’s milk. She insisted the family try their hands at making it, and five years and four flavors later, customers can’t get enough of this delectable treat. We’re thinking ice cream right about now.

Like dulce la leche (a traditional caramel sauce made with cow’s milk), all of the Fat Toad caramel sauces start with milk and sugar. But here, of course, the milk is from goats and the sugar is organic. Choose the original flavor (simply milk and sugar), or go for coffee bean, vanilla bean, or cinnamon for an extra flavor kick. The creamy, sweet sauce tastes familiar at first, but the finish is lent a buttery complexity unlike anything we’ve ever had. The two-jar boxed set comes in a unique wooden box and is perfect for gift-giving, but we wouldn’t blame you one bit if you wanted to keep the deliciousness for yourself.

We heard about the caramel sauce from Bruce Irving, who wanted to share the story of Fat Toad Farm and its DIY origins—and wound up learning more about his sister Judith’s family business in the process. “I knew Daily Grommet reaches an audience that’s on the lookout for the different, the little-known (at least for now!), and the high-quality, but when they posted Fat Toad Farm’s story, complete with a movie, even I was surprised by what I learned and how much I wanted to place an order!”