Need it by 12/24? Order with GROUND shipping by Tuesday, 12/17 at 11:59 PM Pacific. Shop Now.
Skip Navigation


1st Anniversary Gifts

First anniversary gifts are traditionally made with paper. From the perfect card that says I Love You in the just-right way, to a personalized print pinpointing a special spot, take a look at our collection of meaningful (and well-made) first anniversary gifts.

36 Items
of 1
Intimate Art Kit
by LOVE IS ART
starting at
$60.00
Initialed Notepad Stationery
by Black Ink
$40.00
Etched Leather Map Journal
by Tactile Craftworks
$118.00
Themed Historical Prints
by History America
$15.95
Really Big Coloring Poster
by Pirasta
$29.95
Personalized Map Heart Shadow Box
by Define Design 11
$44.10
Etched Leather Map Passport Wallet
by Tactile Craftworks
$60.00
Paper Vase Wraps - Set of 3
by Lucy Grymes
$18.00
Handcrafted Quilled Card - Animals & Wildlife
by Quilling Card
$10.00
Coloring Poster Set
by Zorbitz
$10.47
Handcrafted Quilled Card - Floral
by Quilling Card
$10.00
Digital Custom Pet Portrait
by My Pooch Face
starting at
$169.00
Personalized Skyline Shadow Box
by Define Design 11
$44.10
Handcrafted Quilled Card - Occasion
by Quilling Card
$10.00
Custom Anniversary Sheet Music Art
by Paper'd Moments
starting at
$47.00
Handcrafted Quilled Card - Lifestyle
by Quilling Card
$10.00
The Self Journal
by BestSelf Co.
$31.95
Specialty Notepad Stationery
by Black Ink
$40.00
Felt World Map
by Palomar
starting at
$36.00
Color Maps
by I Lost My Dog
starting at
$39.95
Three Dimensional Country Globe
by Palomar
starting at
$33.00
Custom State Outline Shadow Box
by Define Design 11
$44.10
“And Suddenly" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
no reviews yet
“Most Of All" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
no reviews yet
I (Heart) Us Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
Love Always Wins Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
“Friends, Partners, Husbands" Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
no reviews yet
“Friends, Partners, Wives" Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
“Let's Hear It" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
no reviews yet
“Gentlemen, Congrats" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
“Did" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
“So Many Smiles" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
no reviews yet
“Love of Family" Greeting Card
by Design With Heart
$4.50
no reviews yet
Large Coloring Posters
by Pirasta
$19.95
Calendar Notepad Stationery
by Black Ink
$40.00
Three-Dimensional Paper Globe
by Palomar
$33.00
of 1